Simpson’s big American Idol comeback was undeniably a bold move after 15 years of not performing on live television. While many criticized it, there’s no denying that others warmly welcomed her return—being both nostalgic and inspiring after everything she has gone through.

American Idol season 23 runner-up John Foster shared his gratitude and reflections on performing during the finale alongside incredible artists

The singer delivered her first TV performance in 15 years during the season finale of “American Idol” on May 18. She sang her new track “Blame Me,” before teaming with one of this season’s “Idol” contestants, Josh King, on “These Boots Are Made for Walkin’,” which she recorded in 2005. That song, of course, is a cover of Nancy Sinatra’s 1966 hit.

The May 18 finale lasted three hours and featured performances by the Top 14 and guests like Patti LaBelle, Salt-N-Pepa, The Goo Goo Dolls, Jessica Simpson, Good Charlotte, and others.

Host Ryan Seacrest said there were 26 million votes cast, which broke a record and was twice as many as for last year's finale.

American Idol Season 23 Finale premiered on May 18, 2025. The highly anticipated finale of ABC's iconic singing competition featured many renowned artists.